During my research for BFTL, I encountered numerous cases where reaching out to HR backfired or where employees didn’t even bother because they anticipated the lack of support. So, let’s shed some light on the role of HR and ensure you find the right approach for yourself.
The Purpose of HR
HR’s general role is to manage the entire employee lifecycle, from recruitment and onboarding to training and development, performance management, and employee relations. A well-functioning HR department aims to foster a positive work environment, ensure compliance with labor laws, and support the overall strategic goals of the organization.
When it comes to YOU, struggling under a toxic leader or toxic team, let’s add a little reality check about the role of HR in the corporate world. You might think of HR as the go-to place for support and resolution in the workplace — a kind of workplace guardian angel, right? I’m afraid it’s a bit more complicated than that. Here’s the scoop: HR primarily exists to protect the company’s interests. Now, don’t get me wrong, many HR professionals are genuinely committed to employee well-being. However, at the end of the day, their main job is to safeguard the organization. This means that their decisions, actions, and advice are often influenced by what’s best for the company or the interests of shareholders, even if it comes at the expense of individual employee concerns.
Reaching Out to HR: A Double-Edged Sword
Reaching out to HR can be both a lifeline and a potential risk. Here’s why:
The Lifeline
Support and Guidance: HR professionals are trained to handle workplace issues, including conflicts and toxic work environments. They can provide you with guidance on how to navigate your situation, offer conflict resolution strategies, and mediate discussions with your supervisors or colleagues.
Policy and Procedure Enforcement: HR is responsible for enforcing company policies and procedures. If you’re facing harassment, discrimination, or any form of toxic behavior, HR can take action to address these issues and ensure a safe work environment.
Career Development Opportunities: HR can help you explore career development opportunities within the organization. This might include lateral moves, new roles that better align with your skills and values, or professional development programs to enhance your career prospects.
Mental Health Support: Many HR departments offer Employee Assistance Programs (EAPs) that provide mental health support. These programs can include counseling services, stress management resources, and other forms of support to help you cope with the effects of a toxic work environment.
The Potential Risks
Confidentiality Concerns: While HR is expected to handle matters confidentially, there’s always a risk that your concerns might not be kept entirely private. This can lead to further complications, especially if the individuals involved in the toxicity are made aware of your complaints.
Retaliation: We must not be naive here. While retaliation for taking matters to HR should be a big no-go (alone for legal reasons), it can still occur subtly. If you report toxic behavior, there’s a risk that you might face negative consequences, such as being overlooked for promotions or facing increased scrutiny.
HR’s Dual Loyalty: HR serves both the employees and the organization. Sometimes, this dual loyalty can lead to situations where HR prioritizes the company’s interests over the employees’. It’s important to be aware of this dynamic when seeking HR’s help.
Don’t poke the bear: If your boss has close ties to the head of HR or the executive overseeing HR, reaching out could backfire severely. In these situations, opening up to the wrong people might not only lead to inaction but could also significantly jeopardize your career. Before taking your concerns to HR, I highly recommend to gather information about your boss’s reputation within the organization. Ask yourself questions like, “What’s the general perception of my boss within HR?” or “How did they get hired — was someone in senior management pushing for their appointment?” Understanding these dynamics can help you navigate the situation more strategically and avoid potential career-ending moves.
Making the Most of HR Support
To effectively leverage HR’s support, consider the following steps:
Document Everything: Keep detailed records of all incidents of toxic behavior, including dates, times, locations, and witnesses. This documentation will be crucial when presenting your case to HR.
Know Your Rights: Familiarize yourself with your company’s policies and procedures, as well as your legal rights. This knowledge will empower you to advocate for yourself more effectively.
BEFORE You Reach Out to HR Seek Out Trustworthy Contacts: If you know someone in HR whom you trust, reach out to them. They can provide valuable insights, such as the relationship between HR heads and the toxic individual or division, or how HR handled similar cases in the past. This inside information can give you a clearer idea of what to expect and how to position your concerns. It will also help you evaluate whether reaching out to HR might be more of a chance or more of a risk.
Be Clear and Professional: When discussing your concerns with HR, be clear, concise, and professional. Stick to the facts and avoid getting overly emotional or accusatory.
Follow Up: After your initial meeting with HR, follow up to ensure that your concerns are being addressed. Keep a record of all communications and any actions taken.
Use HR as a Resource for Career Growth: HR can also help you explore new career opportunities within the organization. They can facilitate lateral moves or new roles that better align with your skills and values, enhancing your overall job satisfaction.
Conclusion
The role of HR in navigating and escaping toxic work environments is pivotal. While there are risks involved in reaching out to HR, the potential benefits often outweigh them. By understanding how to effectively engage with HR, you can take proactive steps to protect your well-being and career.
For more insights and strategies on dealing with toxic leadership, don’t forget to check out my book, Breaking Free from Toxic Leadership. It provides comprehensive guidance on recognizing manipulative behaviors, protecting your well-being, and thriving in your career.
Stay tuned for more updates and tips on creating a healthier work environment! If you want to make sure you don’t miss anything you can subscribe to my bi-weekly newsletter here.
Take care,
Markus
Leave a Reply